Site logo
Sticky header logo
GET A DEMO
  • PLATFORM
  • SOLUTIONS
    • For School Safety
    • For Event Security
    • For Law Enforcement
    • For Emergency Management
    • For Fire Safety
    • Public Safety Services
  • ABOUT
    • Leadership Team
    • Our Data Science
    • Careers
    • Case Studies
    • Awards
    • Login
  • BLOG
  • RESOURCES
  • CONTACT
Mobile logo
Sticky header logo
Mobile logo
Sticky header logo
Advanced Threat Analytics Analytics artificial intelligence Bayesian networks cloud solutions cybersecurity emergency response Enterprise Threat Management events field intelligence first responders Haystax Haystax Analytics Haystax Analytics Platform Haystax Technology incident management Insider Threat law enforcement Media Coverage mobile apps Modeling public safety Public Safety Cloud risk management school safety security analytics situational awareness threat analytics threat monitoring user behavior analytics
PrevThe doctor supports a symbol of protection of health.The Healthcare Industry Has a Remedy for Insider Threats22 November 2019NextFinding Edward Snowden: A Haystax Use Case06 December 2019
  • Policy & Practice

The Case for Student Threat Assessments – Part 2

November 27, 2019

It’s been just a few short years since student threat assessments started being conducted at K-12 schools in the U.S. What’s their track record so far? And what are some of the lessons learned that public school districts and charter institutions can embrace moving forward?

The best place to turn for answers to both of these questions is the State of Virginia, the first in the nation to legislatively mandate threat assessment teams.

On November 12, the director of the Virginia Center for School and Campus Safety (VCSCS) under the Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services published a fascinating update and analysis of the effectiveness of the state’s threat assessment program.

VCSCS Director Donna Michaelis said a recent statewide survey showed that: “During the 2017–18 school year, 80% of our K-12 public schools reported conducting at least one threat assessment. Overall, schools reported a total 14,869 threat assessments. Of these cases, 1,472, or about 10%, reached the highest threat level classification at some point in the threat assessment process.”

“When we analyzed the data further,” Michaelis continued, “less than 1% of the 14,869 reported threats actually resulted in a related act being carried out. In total, school officials reported that only 42 of our threat assessment cases included an event taking place, such as a student attempting to harm themselves or others. We believe that’s a pretty good success rate for our teams.”

“The data speaks for itself,” Michaelis wrote. “Threat assessment has been very effective in Virginia.”

Virginia mandated threat assessment teams after two of the most horrific school attacks in the U.S.: first, for higher education in 2007 following the Virginia Tech shooting, and then K-12 schools in 2013 following the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary. It based the programs on recommendations issued jointly by the U.S. Department of Education and the U.S. Secret Service following an earlier mass shooting: Columbine High School in 1999.

Other states have started down the same path, especially in the aftermath of yet another mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida in February 2018.

We described in Part 1 of this post why student threat assessments are a valuable addition to any district or state’s school safety program, noting that they can help “pinpoint the highest-risk individuals among the student population in time to initiate a positive intervention and thus prevent a grimmer outcome.”

And a National Public Radio report broadcast today also notes that prevention in the form of threat assessments and similar early efforts focused on the school climate can be as or more effective than active shooter drills.

As for lessons learned, one of the main ones at VCSCS has been the need for multidisciplinary threat assessment teams and multiple avenues for reporting threatening behaviors. In her recent update, Michaelis said the Virginia teams “require members with expertise in school administration, instruction, counseling, and law enforcement.”

In addition: “Students, parents, and staff have multiple avenues to report concerning behavior to our threat assessment teams, including in-person meetings, anonymous comment boxes, email tip lines, and phone or text message systems. These teams then work together to assess the individual’s behavior and intervene with those whose behavior may pose a threat.”

Other lessons learned, according to Michaelis:

  • It is critical that proposed threat assessment legislation be fully vetted and reviewed by educators before implementation, so everyone understands the width and breadth of what is trying to be accomplished.
  • It is important that a state agency be given the directive to develop model policies and procedures, handle data collection and conduct training.
  • It is better to do more specific, targeted training at an individual school, rather than organizing statewide sessions where there are 50 representatives from 50 different divisions.
  • One person cannot be solely responsible for going back to their division and implementing a threat assessment team. A more effective training model is one that includes an entire school staff or division.

But perhaps the biggest lesson learned for VCSCS was the need for a proactive community outreach program for students, parents and their surrounding communities, many of whom are concerned that the assessments are tantamount to ‘spying on the kids.’

Michaels said, “we knew that some parents would see this as ‘big brother,’ or schools labeling their child and this label possibly following them into college or the community. To address this concern, we created a marketing campaign, Virginia CARES, to better explain threat assessment teams to our parents.”

The message, she stressed, is that “the goal of threat assessment is to prevent a child from committing an act of violence against themselves or others and to get them the help they need; it is not meant to be a disciplinary process.”

#   #   #

Note: If you’re responsible for school safety, it’s well worth reading Michaelis’s informed and insightful update in full. Notes From the Field: The Value of Threat Assessment Teams can be found on the U.S. Department of Justice’s National Institute of Justice (NIJ) website.

  • school safety
  • threat assessments

Related posts

Policy & Practice Preventing School Violence: Challenges and Opportunities
October 20, 2021in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 0 Likes

Preventing School Violence: Challenges and Opportunities

Product Updates Haystax Product Update: Turbocharging Asset Maps
September 13, 2021in Product Updates 0 Comments 0 Likes

Haystax Product Update: Turbocharging Asset Maps

Product Updates Assessment template builder
May 12, 2021in Product Updates 0 Comments 4 Likes

Haystax Product Update: Assessment Template Builder

Policy & Practice school safety assessment
August 31, 2020in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 5 Likes

DoJ Deems Risk Assessments ‘Essential’ for School Safety

Success Stories Hurricanes Add to Risks in a Multi-Hazard Year
August 21, 2020in Success Stories 0 Comments 1 Likes

Hurricanes Add to Risks in a Multi-Hazard Year

Company News Haystax School Safety Users to Speak at ASIS Conference
May 7, 2020in Company News 0 Comments 1 Likes

Haystax School Safety Users to Speak at ASIS Conference

Product Updates assessment
April 15, 2020in Product Updates 0 Comments 7 Likes

Haystax Product Update: Insider Threat and Facility Assessments

Success Stories Inside the Public Safety Community’s Coronavirus Response
March 26, 2020in Success Stories 0 Comments 3 Likes

Inside the Public Safety Community’s Coronavirus Response

Company News Haystax Wins Triple Gold in Cybersecurity Excellence Awards
February 21, 2020in Company News 0 Comments 6 Likes

Haystax Wins Triple Gold in Cybersecurity Excellence Awards

Policy & Practice The Case for Student Threat Assessments – Part 1
November 15, 2019in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 0 Likes

The Case for Student Threat Assessments – Part 1

Technology & Data Science School Domain Awareness Defined
October 21, 2019in Technology & Data Science 0 Comments 3 Likes

School Domain Awareness Defined

Policy & Practice The Lessons of Umpqua
October 1, 2019in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 0 Likes

The Lessons of Umpqua

Product Updates Haystax Product Update: Empowering Tenant Admins
September 12, 2019in Product Updates 0 Comments 5 Likes

Haystax Product Update: Empowering Tenant Admins

Policy & Practice Balancing School Risks in the Year of the Mass Shooter
August 22, 2019in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 0 Likes

Balancing School Risks in the Year of the Mass Shooter

Policy & Practice The Parkland Tragedy, One Year Later
February 14, 2019in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 0 Likes

The Parkland Tragedy, One Year Later

Product Updates Haystax Product Update: Streamlined Assessment Workflows
December 26, 2018in Product Updates 0 Comments 4 Likes

Haystax Product Update: Streamlined Assessment Workflows

Policy & Practice Towards a More Holistic Approach to Managing School Safety Risk
December 14, 2018in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 1 Likes

Towards a More Holistic Approach to Managing School Safety Risk

Product Updates Haystax Product Update: Next-Gen Field Reporting
October 4, 2018in Product Updates 0 Comments 8 Likes

Haystax Product Update: Next-Gen Field Reporting

Policy & Practice school safety assessment
April 19, 2018in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 3 Likes

Want Safer Schools? Start with an Assessment

Company News public safety
March 5, 2018in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

Haystax Technology Named Top Public Safety Innovator

Success Stories school safety
January 30, 2018in Success Stories 0 Comments 2 Likes

FSSAT to Boost School Safety and Emergency Awareness in Florida

Product Updates Haystax Product Update: Improving Assessment Functionality, User Workflows
December 20, 2017in Product Updates 0 Comments 0 Likes

Haystax Product Update: Improving Assessment Functionality, User Workflows

Success Stories school safety
July 17, 2017in Success Stories 0 Comments 1 Likes

Florida Enters Third Year of School Safety Assessment Program

Company News Security analytics
February 13, 2017in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

Haystax Technology Wins Two Cybersecurity Awards Ahead of RSA Conference

Company News security analytics
February 3, 2017in Company News 0 Comments 2 Likes

Haystax Named Finalist for 2017 Cybersecurity Excellence Awards

Technology & Data Science Most Campuses Have Security Cameras. Now What?
August 19, 2016in Technology & Data Science 0 Comments 5 Likes

Most Campuses Have Security Cameras. Now What?

Product Updates Using Information Sharing to Combat Automated Bomb Threats Against Schools
June 8, 2016in Product Updates 0 Comments 0 Likes

Using Information Sharing to Combat Automated Bomb Threats Against Schools

Policy & Practice Threats in LA, NY, FL and TX may have been hoaxes, but terrorism in schools is a real threat
December 20, 2015in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 0 Likes

Threats in LA, NY, FL and TX may have been hoaxes, but terrorism in schools is a real threat

Company News Haystax provides industry perspective on managing school safety in the digital age
December 1, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 1 Likes

Haystax provides industry perspective on managing school safety in the digital age

Company News Haystax Technology Presents at the National Center for Education Research & Technology (NCERT) Summit
October 28, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 1 Likes

Haystax Technology Presents at the National Center for Education Research & Technology (NCERT) Summit

Company News Haystax Awarded Most Innovative Technology for School Safety
October 27, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

Haystax Awarded Most Innovative Technology for School Safety

Company News Managing School Safety in the 21st Century – Webcast
October 22, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 3 Likes

Managing School Safety in the 21st Century – Webcast

Policy & Practice The Umpqua Tragedy: Lessons Learned in School Safety
October 7, 2015in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 0 Likes

The Umpqua Tragedy: Lessons Learned in School Safety

Company News Center for Digital Education Reports on LASPD School Safety Assessments
September 28, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

Center for Digital Education Reports on LASPD School Safety Assessments

Company News KGBT-TV Highlights McAllen ISD Using Haystax Software to Monitor Students’ Safety
September 23, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

KGBT-TV Highlights McAllen ISD Using Haystax Software to Monitor Students’ Safety

Company News LA School Report Examines Collaboration between LASPD and Haystax Technology
September 23, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

LA School Report Examines Collaboration between LASPD and Haystax Technology

Policy & Practice The Importance Of School Safety Planning
September 23, 2015in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 1 Likes

The Importance Of School Safety Planning

Company News Regional Tech Innovation Challenge Chooses Haystax School Safety Solution as Finalist
September 16, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

Regional Tech Innovation Challenge Chooses Haystax School Safety Solution as Finalist

Company News THE Journal highlights LASPD mobile school assessment tool, developed by Haystax Technology
September 9, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 1 Likes

THE Journal highlights LASPD mobile school assessment tool, developed by Haystax Technology

Product Updates LA School Police Dept. Completes First Round of Safety Assessments Using Haystax Mobile App
September 3, 2015in Product Updates 0 Comments 1 Likes

LA School Police Dept. Completes First Round of Safety Assessments Using Haystax Mobile App

Company News Haystax Technology to Demonstrate Broad Public Safety Offerings, Host First Users Session at National Homeland Security Conference in San Antonio
June 9, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

Haystax Technology to Demonstrate Broad Public Safety Offerings, Host First Users Session at National Homeland Security Conference in San Antonio

Company News U.S. News & World Report quotes Haystax Technology on School Safety
May 22, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

U.S. News & World Report quotes Haystax Technology on School Safety

Company News Center for Digital Education shows how schools can leverage Haystax Technology’s School Safety Center
May 21, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 1 Likes

Center for Digital Education shows how schools can leverage Haystax Technology’s School Safety Center

Policy & Practice Terrorism Risk and Schools: Time to Take Note (Part II)
May 19, 2015in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 1 Likes

Terrorism Risk and Schools: Time to Take Note (Part II)

Policy & Practice Terrorism Risk and Schools: Time to Take Note (Part I)
May 14, 2015in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 0 Likes

Terrorism Risk and Schools: Time to Take Note (Part I)

Product Updates Baltimore School Warning Was Just a Tweet Away
May 7, 2015in Product Updates 0 Comments 0 Likes

Baltimore School Warning Was Just a Tweet Away

Company News KFXV-LD in McAllen, Texas Highlights New School Safety Center Solution from Haystax
May 7, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

KFXV-LD in McAllen, Texas Highlights New School Safety Center Solution from Haystax

Company News Haystax Technology’s School Safety Center featured in The Monitor (TX)
April 30, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 1 Likes

Haystax Technology’s School Safety Center featured in The Monitor (TX)

Company News KGBT-TV (CBS) Reports on Haystax Technology’s School Safety Center Solution
April 30, 2015in Company News 0 Comments 3 Likes

KGBT-TV (CBS) Reports on Haystax Technology’s School Safety Center Solution

Success Stories Haystax Technology Enhances School Safety for McAllen Independent School District
April 28, 2015in Success Stories 0 Comments 0 Likes

Haystax Technology Enhances School Safety for McAllen Independent School District

Policy & Practice School Threats on the Rise
April 14, 2015in Policy & Practice 0 Comments 0 Likes

School Threats on the Rise

Company News The Journal Highlights Haystax School Safety Technology
October 30, 2014in Company News 0 Comments 2 Likes

The Journal Highlights Haystax School Safety Technology

Success Stories Haystax Helps Florida Strengthen School Safety
October 23, 2014in Success Stories 0 Comments 0 Likes

Haystax Helps Florida Strengthen School Safety

Company News Police Chief Magazine Highlights Haystax National School Safety Cloud Launch
May 12, 2014in Company News 0 Comments 0 Likes

Police Chief Magazine Highlights Haystax National School Safety Cloud Launch

Company News Indy uses emergency preparedness technology to respond to disasters
February 3, 2014in Company News 0 Comments 1 Likes

Indy uses emergency preparedness technology to respond to disasters

The Latest at Haystax

Preventing School Violence: Challenges and Opportunities
Preventing School Violence: Challenges and Opportunities
2021 Insider Threat Lessons Learned
2021 Insider Threat Lessons Learned
Haystax Insider Threat Expert Contributes to INSA Paper
Haystax Insider Threat Expert Contributes to INSA Paper

DOWNLOAD FREE GUIDE

READ THE LATEST INSIDER THREAT REPORT

Tags

Advanced Threat Analytics Analytics cybersecurity Enterprise Threat Management first responders Haystax Analytics Haystax Analytics Platform Haystax Technology Insider Threat Media Coverage public safety risk management security analytics situational awareness threat monitoring

Follow Haystax on Social

Categories

  • Company News (147)
  • Policy & Practice (66)
  • Product Updates (48)
  • Success Stories (30)
  • Technology & Data Science (52)

Haystax’s security analytics platform applies artificial intelligence techniques to reason like a team of analysts and prioritize risks in real time at scale for more efficient protection of critical assets.

877-442-4553

Contact Haystax

© Haystax 2022 - A Fishtech LLC company. All rights reserved.